WWE 2K25 Review: A New World Order, or Just More of the Same?

The Good, the Bad, and the…Slightly Less Bad

Pro wrestling *is* a variety show. That’s a truism, and it’s something that WWE 2K25, in theory, should nail. Spend a few weeks watching WWE programming and you’ll see how much they strive for variety; segments flit between high-stakes drama, over-the-top action, slapstick comedy, and even moments that verge on the surreal and horrifying. The matches themselves? They aim for a broad appeal, balancing technical prowess with spectacle. But does 2K25 manage to capture this chaotic energy in a fun and engaging videogame? The answer, unfortunately, is a bit more nuanced than a simple yes or no.

Let’s start with the positives. The graphics are undoubtedly improved. Character models are more detailed, arenas feel more alive, and the overall presentation is a significant step up from previous iterations. This is especially noticeable in the character creation suite; the level of customization is impressive, allowing you to build almost anyone imaginable, from a realistic superstar to a fantastical monstrosity. There’s even increased control over entrance design, enabling genuinely unique and personalized arrivals.

The gameplay, while familiar to veterans, has received some welcome tweaks. The controls feel more responsive, allowing for a more fluid and satisfying wrestling experience. Chain wrestling is smoother, reversals are more intuitive, and the overall pacing feels better balanced. The addition of new grappling animations further enhances the sense of realism and brutality. However, the AI remains a persistent frustration, with opponents occasionally exhibiting questionable decision-making and a tendency to ignore strategic advantages.

Beyond the core wrestling engine, the MyGM mode gets a boost. The increased depth in managerial choices, including roster building, contracts, rivalries, and promotional strategies, makes for a much more compelling management experience compared to past versions. However, the MyRise mode feels a bit underdeveloped. The storyline lacks the same captivating narrative arcs that have been present in other sports games’ career modes.

Areas Needing a Chokeslam

Despite its advancements, 2K25 stumbles in several crucial areas. The story mode, while offering a glimpse into the world of WWE, feels disappointingly predictable and lacks genuine emotional impact. The cutscenes, while visually impressive, fail to capture the nuances of character development or the intensity of wrestling rivalries. The narrative falls short of the heights achieved in other wrestling games. The core problem? A lack of creative risk-taking. The stories are familiar, predictable, and ultimately forgettable.

Another significant issue is the online experience. While playing against other players provides a certain level of thrill, lag and connection issues remain persistent problems. The matchmaking system could also use some serious improvements, as finding appropriately skilled opponents is often a frustrating chore.

Finally, the commentary, a perennial weak point in wrestling games, continues to feel repetitive and lacking in dynamism. While the commentators’ voices and energy are good, their lines don’t change enough to keep up with the variation in match outcomes and events.

Overall Verdict: A Mixed Bag

WWE 2K25 represents a step forward in several areas, particularly in its graphics, gameplay refinements, and MyGM mode’s depth. However, its persistent shortcomings in the story mode, online stability, and commentary, prevent it from achieving greatness. It’s a solid game but not a revolutionary one. It’s a game that fans will enjoy, but one which doesn’t quite capture the chaotic energy and genuine unpredictability that defines professional wrestling itself. Is it worth the price of admission? That depends on your expectations and tolerance for lingering frustrations. If you are a die-hard WWE fan who’s invested in the MyGM mode and doesn’t mind wrestling AI’s shortcomings, it might very well be. For others, perhaps waiting for a future iteration that fully realizes the potential of the WWE license would be the wiser choice.

Tips for a better experience:

• Experiment with different character builds in MyCareer.
• Focus on mastering the new grappling mechanics.
• Play around with different match types and stipulations.
• Be patient with the AI; it isn’t perfect, but it can be overcome.
• Manage your expectations concerning the online mode and commentary.